Tuesday, January 4, 2011

Blog topic 1


I believe that stereotyping for the most part affects our society as a whole negatively.  For each of the four different cultures covered in the first four chapters each stereotype had a negative impact on each culture by making each culture over simplified. 

For the African Americans it was negative because in the minstrel plays they were portraying slaves as being happy to serve their masters, and made it seem like slavery was fun.  For these plays Caucasian people were painting their faces black and portraying African Americans.  For the reversal minstrels plays, African American  people were painting their faces white and making fun of the minstrel plays by exaggerating the stereotypes of blacks even more.  In the video for “Day of Absence” you could hear people laughing at how extreme the stereotypes were of the white-faced actors talking to the black actor that was portraying a slave.

For the Latino and Mexican stereotyping it was definitely a negative impact, even though it portrayed some of the people as very hard workers, they were trying to sell them like cars in “Los Venditos”.  The clip also portrayed them as being able to live anywhere, even in the worst neighborhoods in the most dilapidated buildings.  It was also very offensive to me that the college students were dressing up as Mexican janitors and wearing names like Pedro and Sanchez in the representations of the media clip.  This does not make our colleges look very accepting of other nations and is just ignorant to me.

For Native American stereotypes, they were almost always portrayed as villains in the older movies, that’s why it was nice to see a movie like “Dances with Wolves” when it came out.  It finally was a movie that showed that white people may have been the ones that were the villains.  After watching the clips of the “White Shamans and Plastic Medicine Men” I felt bad for the Natives and Indians because they are right it is wrong to try to profit from pretending to be healers, especially when true healers don’t charge for their “services”.

For the Asian-American stereotypes, they seemed to have the most positive ones but, this still is a way of making everyone seem the same.  When some people might be good at math while others aren’t and excel at some other subject, just like any other race or nationality.  The idea of the obedient woman with Asian culture made it seem like Asian women and Indian women were like robots and would just do what their husband said.  Which, no matter where this idea came from it is not fair to say this about anyone, it kind of makes them sound like they don’t have a say in what they do.

The media just spreads these stereotypes faster and is not helping us to break the stereotypes any time soon.  Certain movies don’t help either like “A day without a Mexican” that was a prime example of stereotyping with all of the low end jobs being empty since all of the Mexicans were gone.  

2 comments:

  1. I also thought the clip with the college students that dressed up as the janitors with the Hispanic names was offensive to me also. Like you said, that shows just complete ignorance and just makes me so upset that college students would go that far. It makes me so disappointed to see our generation stooping to that and being so completely oblivious, and worst of all what would ever make them think that would be okay? Media does help these stereotypes faster, I agree with you there, especially when no matter where you go you basically can't escape it. Even if you try to say that media does not effect us, it does. It is everywhere telling us what certain people are like or how to look or act. It is such a sad thing when the media is perpetuating these prejudices.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You brought up a lot of good points in your response. Like Emily’s response you also talk a lot about ignorance. I agree it makes colleges look extremely ignorant and non accepting to put on plays so full of stereotypes. I really don’t feel like these plays even if humor is involved is helping us as a society get past all of these horrible thoughts. You also make a great point about Asian-American stereotypes. Even if they are mostly positive that doesn’t mean its good to assume things about other cultures. Everyone is different, even in the same race. One Asian-American may be a math wizard and another may not be able to pass a basic algebra class. I think many people would wonder why bother worrying about stereotypes if they are not negative but I think its just as offensive to assume someone is good at something when they are not. It doesn’t make the person feel good if they are not good at it and everyone assumes they are. When that person can’t perform the task everyone assumes they can, i can see this being a big problem.

    ReplyDelete